Draft for review, not published

Does SMSF property need valuing every three years? What the ATO actually requires

Direct answer

No. There is no three-year rule in the regulations or the ATO's guide: SMSF assets, including property, must be valued at market value each year when the accounts are prepared. The value must rest on objective, supportable data. A provider, online or agent report is acceptable if it lists the comparable sales relied on, and one item of evidence is generally not enough. Auditors must see sufficient appropriate evidence.

The annual requirement

SMSF property must be valued at market value every year the fund prepares its accounts. Regulation 8.02B of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 requires fund assets to be valued at market value when the accounts are prepared2. The ATO’s Guide to valuing SMSF assets, last updated 15 May 2026, explains how trustees meet that requirement1. For the full picture of reports and prices, see our page on SMSF property valuations.

Neither the regulation nor the ATO’s guide mentions valuing property every three years. That is our reading of both documents: the three-year rule is not in them.

Where the idea probably comes from is a real feature of the guide. The ATO does not require a qualified independent valuer every year. Some funds therefore commission a full valuation less often and support the value in the years between with other evidence. That is a practice some funds follow, not a rule, and the value still has to be supportable every year.

What the ATO guide accepts as evidence

The guide accepts reports from several kinds of provider. Its words are: “A valuation done by a property valuation service provider, including online services or a real estate agent, are acceptable.”1

It then sets two conditions that matter more than the list of providers:

  1. Comparable sales. If a provider’s report is the only evidence, it should list the comparable sales it relied on.
  2. More than one item. “Generally, it is not sufficient for valuations to be based on only one item of evidence.”1

Behind both is the general standard: the value must be based on objective and supportable data. A figure from an online tool that shows no sales, or an agent’s letter that states a number without evidence, gives an auditor nothing to test.

The table below sets out what each ATO source says, with its date and the exact words.

SourceDateWhat it saysQuote
SIS Regulations, reg 8.02BCompilation No. 159, 1 July 2026Fund assets are valued at market value when the accounts are preparedParaphrase; no quote taken
ATO, Guide to valuing SMSF assetsLast updated 15 May 2026Reports from providers, online services and agents are acceptable; if a report is the only evidence it should list the comparable sales relied on"A valuation done by a property valuation service provider, including online services or a real estate agent, are acceptable"
ATO, Guide to valuing SMSF assetsLast updated 15 May 2026One item of evidence is generally not enough"Generally, it is not sufficient for valuations to be based on only one item of evidence"
ATO, Guide to valuing SMSF assetsLast updated 15 May 2026Consider a qualified independent valuer for a significant or complex assetTrustees "should consider" one where an asset "represents a significant proportion of the fund's value"
ATO, Guide to valuing SMSF assetsLast updated 15 May 2026Values should be consistent with any CGT value for the same event"there's no evidence a different value was used for the corresponding capital gains tax event"
ATO, Verifying the market value of fund assets (for auditors)Last updated 2 April 2025Agent appraisals, recent contracts and comparable sales are evidence; an appraisal without the sales relied on is weak alone"would generally not on its own be sufficient"
ATO, Division 296 and SMSF auditsLast updated 31 August 2026Division 296 does not change the auditor's evidence requirement"does not change" the need for "sufficient and appropriate audit evidence"

When a qualified independent valuer is required or advisable

A qualified independent valuer is legally required in only one case under the ATO’s guide: collectables and personal-use assets disposed of to related parties1. Fund property held in the ordinary way does not trigger it.

The guide goes further for assets that carry more weight. It says trustees “should consider” a qualified independent valuer where an asset “represents a significant proportion of the fund’s value”, or where it is complex to value1. “Should consider” is not a requirement. Where a single property is the fund’s largest asset, though, that is the situation the sentence is written for.

What the auditor checks

The auditor, not the trustee or the valuer, decides whether the evidence of market value is sufficient. The ATO’s page for SMSF auditors, last updated 2 April 2025, lists the kinds of evidence an auditor may see: agent appraisals (“or kerbside”), recent contracts and comparable sales. It says an agent appraisal without the sales relied on “would generally not on its own be sufficient”3.

Division 296 has not changed this. On 31 August 2026 the ATO told auditors that Division 296 “does not change” their need for “sufficient and appropriate audit evidence” of market value4. That applies to funds that make the Division 296 cost-base election5 as much as to those that don’t.

Consistency with other values

The ATO will generally accept a fund’s value if, among other things, “there’s no evidence a different value was used for the corresponding capital gains tax event”1. In plain terms, the fund should not report one value in its accounts and use another for a CGT calculation on the same property at the same date.

This matters most in years when something else happens to the property: a transfer to or from a member, a sale, or a cost-base election. One report, with one figure used for every purpose at that date, avoids the conflict.

A practical evidence pattern

What follows is general information, not a rule and not advice. It describes one way funds can meet the guide’s two conditions over several years. Your accountant and auditor decide what suits the fund.

Year Evidence Why it fits the guide
A year with a full valuation A valuation that lists comparable sales, signed by a valuer Comparable sales listed; a valuer’s opinion as well as the sales data
A year between full valuations A market value estimate (not a valuation) that lists comparable sales, plus another item such as a recent contract or other sales evidence Comparable sales listed; more than one item of evidence
A year when the value may have moved A fresh valuation The update method no longer reflects the property

Three situations are reasons to consider a fresh valuation rather than an update:

  • the local market has moved materially since the last valuation;
  • the property has had major works, damage or a change of use;
  • the property is a significant share of the fund’s value, which is where the guide says trustees “should consider” an independent valuer.

How ValueEdge reports line up

Each of our reports is labelled with what it is. The table shows what each contains against the points above.

ReportTagLists comparable salesSigned byInspection
Market value estimate ($195)Not a valuationYes [TBC: confirm the estimate report lists the comparable sales relied on]No one; data model checked by staffNone
Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) ($249)Signed by a CPV · indicative value under API rulesYes [TBC: confirm with the Lead CPV that every desktop report lists the comparable sales relied on]A Certified Practising ValuerNone
Inspected valuation ($550)Valuation, signed by a CPVYesThe Certified Practising Valuer who inspectedFull internal, with the inspection date

The market value estimate is not a valuation. It is designed as one item of evidence for the years between full valuations.

The Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) is signed by a Certified Practising Valuer of the Australian Property Institute but does not involve an inspection. Under the API’s Rule 12.2, a desktop “can only result in an indicative value” and is not an IVS-compliant valuation6. It is intended for annual SMSF reporting on standard residential property. It is not suitable for a CGT cost base or for court.

The inspected valuation is a valuation under API Rule 11.2, because the signing valuer inspects the property6.

None of these reports, on its own, settles whether the evidence is sufficient. That remains the auditor’s decision. Auditors and administrators can see the full contents of each report.

Frequently asked questions

Is there an ATO rule to value SMSF property every three years?

No. Neither the SIS Regulations nor the ATO's Guide to valuing SMSF assets mentions a three-year cycle. Fund assets are valued at market value whenever the accounts are prepared, which is every year. What the ATO does not require is a qualified independent valuer every year, which may be where the three-year idea comes from.

Do SMSFs have to value property every year?

Yes. SMSF assets must be valued at market value when preparing the fund's accounts each year (SISR reg 8.02B). The ATO doesn't require a qualified independent valuer each year, but suggests one where a property is a significant part of the fund or complex to value. Values must be based on objective and supportable data.

Is an agent appraisal or online report enough?

The ATO's SMSF guide says reports from valuation providers, "including online services or a real estate agent, are acceptable", but if that is the only evidence the report should list the comparable sales relied on, and one item of evidence is generally not enough. Auditors must see sufficient appropriate evidence of market value.

Does the valuer have to be independent?

Not always. The ATO's guide legally requires a qualified independent valuer only for collectables and personal-use assets disposed of to related parties. For other assets, trustees "should consider" one where an asset represents a significant proportion of the fund's value or is complex to value.

Does Division 296 change what auditors need?

No. The ATO told SMSF auditors on 31 August 2026 that Division 296 "does not change" their need for sufficient and appropriate audit evidence of each asset's market value. A fund that makes the Division 296 cost-base election still needs supportable values, and the auditor still decides whether the evidence is enough.

What date should the SMSF valuation be at?

The date at which the fund's accounts value its assets, which for most funds is 30 June of the financial year being reported. Confirm the date with the fund's accountant or administrator before ordering, because a report valued at the wrong date may need to be redone.

Sources

  1. Guide to valuing SMSF assets (QC 26343), last updated 15 May 2026 — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  2. Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994, reg 8.02B (Compilation No. 159) — Federal Register of Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  3. Verifying the market value of fund assets (SMSF auditors, QC 60021), last updated 2 April 2025 — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  4. Division 296 and SMSF audits (QC 107972), last updated 31 August 2026 — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  5. About Division 296 tax for SMSFs (QC 107628), last updated 29 June 2026 — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  6. Rules of Professional Conduct, effective 1 August 2025 — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.