Draft for review, not published

For SMSF auditors and administrators

Property valuation evidence for SMSF auditors and administrators

SMSF auditors must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence of each property's market value, and the ATO says an agent appraisal without the sales relied on would generally not be enough on its own. Every ValueEdge report lists the comparable sales used, the valuation date, the method and who prepared it, and says plainly whether it is an estimate or a valuation signed by a Certified Practising Valuer.

[TBC: confirm the market value estimate report lists the comparable sales relied on. If it does not, change "Every ValueEdge report" to "Every ValueEdge valuation" and change the estimate column in B2.]

What the ATO says auditors need

The auditor decides whether the evidence of market value is sufficient. Three pieces of ATO guidance set the frame, quoted exactly and dated below.

ATO source and date What it says
Verifying the market value of fund assets (for SMSF auditors), last updated 2 April 2025 Lists agent appraisals ("or kerbside"), recent contracts and comparable sales as evidence. An agent appraisal without the sales relied on "would generally not on its own be sufficient". (S55)
Guide to valuing SMSF assets, last updated 15 May 2026 "Generally, it is not sufficient for valuations to be based on only one item of evidence." Where a provider's report is the only evidence, it should list the comparable sales relied on. (S13)
Division 296 and SMSF audits, last updated 31 August 2026 Division 296 "does not change" the need for "sufficient and appropriate audit evidence" of market value. (S17)

Read the full guidance, quote by quote

What's in each report

This is what each report contains. It is not a statement of what you will conclude from it.

Item Market value estimate (not a valuation) Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) Inspected valuation
Valuation date Stated Stated Stated
Purpose stated Yes Yes Yes
Comparable sales listed Yes [TBC: confirm] Yes Yes
Method stated Yes Yes Yes
Inspection None None Full internal, with the inspection date
Signed by No one; data model checked by staff A Certified Practising Valuer The Certified Practising Valuer who inspected
Status under API rules Not a valuation Indicative value (API Rule 12.2) Valuation (API Rule 11.2)
Independence declaration Not applicable Yes Yes
Price incl. GST $195 $249 $550

See the report layout

Which report suits which fund

Each report has a different job. The auditor decides whether the evidence for a particular fund and year is sufficient.

  • Market value estimate ($195, not a valuation). A data-model figure checked by our staff, with no valuer's opinion and no inspection. It is designed as one item of evidence for the years between full valuations. The ATO's guide says one item of evidence is generally not sufficient (S13), so an estimate is not designed to stand alone.
  • Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) ($249). A Certified Practising Valuer forms an opinion from records and sales data and signs, without visiting. Under API Rule 12.2 it gives an indicative value only and is not an IVS-compliant valuation (S21). It is intended for annual reporting on standard residential property. It is not suitable for a CGT cost base or court.
  • Inspected valuation ($550). The signing Certified Practising Valuer inspects the property inside and out, which makes it a valuation under API Rule 11.2 (S21). It suits a property that is a significant share of the fund or complex to value, the situation in which the ATO's guide says trustees "should consider" a qualified independent valuer (S13).
  • Specialist valuation (quoted, from $650). Commercial property, property over $3 million and related-party transfers, prepared by a CPV with relevant experience. [TBC: confirm a CPV able to sign commercial SMSF valuations is in place at launch]

Our SMSF programme is a full valuation in year one, then a $195 market value estimate in each of years 2 to 5, with a fresh valuation if values move materially. [TBC: what counts as a material move] [TBC: whether the year-one full valuation can be a desktop or must be inspected] The programme is explained on the SMSF page

Division 296: values as at 30 June 2026

Funds considering the Division 296 cost-base election need each asset's market value as at the end of 30 June 2026 (S14). That date has passed, so we prepare these as retrospective valuations as at the end of 30 June 2026, using only evidence known at that date, and the report says it is retrospective. They can be ordered now. [TBC: whether a 30 June 2026 SMSF value is ordered at standard desktop or inspected prices or quoted as a specialist valuation from $650]

The ATO's approved election form had not been issued at its page's last update (29 June 2026).

The Division 296 cost-base reset - Label: Division 296 election form · State: pending · Text: The ATO says "an approved form will be provided in due course". Not issued at the ATO page's last update (29 June 2026). · Source: S14 · As at: 17 Nov 2026

Independence

  • The valuer is independent of the fund, the trustees, the members and any real estate agent involved with the property.
  • The fee is agreed before work starts and never depends on the value.
  • The founders of ValueEdge also run a buyers agency. They never form or influence an opinion of value, and ValueEdge does not value a property their agency has acted on.
  • Each signed report names the signing Certified Practising Valuer. You can check their certification with the Australian Property Institute (S104).

Our independence policy

For administrators: ordering across many funds

Administrators and accounting practices can order for many funds at once.

  1. Open a business account.
  2. Upload a spreadsheet (CSV or .xlsx) with one row per property, or order one at a time.
  3. We confirm each property, the report type and the price before any work starts.
  4. The report goes to the trustees and, where the trustees consent, to the administrator and the auditor.
  5. One invoice a month.

Partner pricing for administrators: [TBC: partner discount].

  • Spreadsheet columns fund_name · fund_abn · client_reference · trustee_name · trustee_email · property_address · suburb · state · postcode · property_type · purpose (SMSF annual / Division 296 at 30 June 2026 / in-specie transfer / other) · valuation_date · product · share_report_with_administrator (Y/N; trustee consent required) · auditor_email (report sent only with trustee consent) · notes

We send a report to an administrator or auditor only where the trustees have consented. Each property is checked before we confirm the order.

  • Builder note: no integration with SMSF administration software exists. Do not add logos or "integrates with" copy.

Verifying a report

Every report carries a report ID. To confirm a report is genuine and unaltered: [TBC: report verification method, for example a verification contact or lookup by report ID].

The SMSF auditor evidence note

One page that maps what each ValueEdge report contains against the ATO's auditor guidance and its SMSF valuation guide, with the dates of each source. "Download the evidence note" We use your email to send the note and, if you tick the box, occasional updates. We do not share it.

Download the evidence note

Preview only. Your request is recorded locally; no email is sent.

Common questions

Is an estimate enough evidence for an audit?

The market value estimate is not a valuation. It lists the comparable sales relied on [TBC: confirm] and is designed as one item of evidence. The ATO's guide says "Generally, it is not sufficient for valuations to be based on only one item of evidence". Whether an estimate, with or without other evidence, is sufficient is the auditor's decision.

Who signs your valuations, and can I check them?

A Certified Practising Valuer of the Australian Property Institute signs every Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection), inspected valuation and specialist valuation, and the report names them. You can check their certification with the API. To confirm a report itself is genuine: [TBC: report verification method].

Do you inspect?

For an inspected valuation, yes: the Certified Practising Valuer who signs the report inspects the property in person, which makes it a valuation under API Rule 11.2. A Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) involves no visit and gives an indicative value under API Rule 12.2. The estimate involves no visit and is not a valuation.

Can you provide 30 June 2026 values for Division 296?

Yes. We prepare them as retrospective valuations as at the end of 30 June 2026, using only evidence known at that date, and the report says it is retrospective. The Division 296 election covers all the fund's CGT assets, is irrevocable, and is due by the fund's 2026–27 annual return due date.

Can reports be sent straight to the auditor?

Yes, if the trustees consent when ordering. We send a report only to the people the trustees name. Administrators ordering in bulk can include the auditor's email in the spreadsheet; the report goes to the auditor only where the trustee has consented.

Do you pay auditors referral fees?

[TBC: auditor referral policy. Brief's proposed answer, to confirm with James: "No. We do not pay referral fees to SMSF auditors, because an auditor must stay independent of the evidence they assess."]

Open a business account

We call within two business days to set up the account and send the spreadsheet template. [TBC: confirm the call-back commitment]

Preview only. Your request is recorded locally; no email is sent.

Open decisions for this draft
  • [TBC: …]

Sources

  1. Verifying the market value of fund assets (SMSF auditors, QC 60021), last updated 2 April 2025 · Accessed 17 November 2026
  2. Guide to valuing SMSF assets (QC 26343), last updated 15 May 2026 · Accessed 17 November 2026
  3. Division 296 and SMSF audits (QC 107972), last updated 31 August 2026 · Accessed 17 November 2026
  4. About Division 296 tax for SMSFs (QC 107628), last updated 29 June 2026 · Accessed 17 November 2026
  5. Rules of Professional Conduct, effective 1 August 2025 · Accessed 17 November 2026
  6. Certified Practising Valuer certification pages · Accessed 17 November 2026

Information as at 17 November 2026. Sources: ATO guidance and market valuations, the reset legislation, draft apportionment method, API professional rules. Speak to your registered tax agent about your circumstances.