Draft for review, not published

Property valuation reports: the types, and which is which

Direct answer

A property valuation report is a valuer's signed opinion of market value at a stated date. Under Australian Property Institute rules a valuation needs a physical inspection by the signing valuer; a desktop report gives only an indicative value, and an automated estimate involves no valuer at all. Which report you need depends on the purpose: tax, super, court, a sale or curiosity.

Where the law stands

As at
ATO valuation guidance for the reset
pendingOn 19 October 2026 the ATO promised guidance on valuation methods, the types of professional to consider and the records required. Not published as at 17 November 2026.Source ·

In this section: Market value estimate · Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) · Inspected valuation

What makes a report a “valuation”

A report is a valuation, in the professional sense, when a qualified valuer has physically inspected the property and signed an opinion of its market value at a stated date. Anything less can still be useful, but it is something else: an estimate, an appraisal or an indicative value.

That line is drawn by the Australian Property Institute (API), whose rules bind its member valuers. Rule 11.2 says a valuation requires a physical inspection by the Primary Valuer, the person who takes responsibility for the report. The inspection can be comprehensive (inside and out), limited on-site, or limited off-site, which is a kerbside inspection from the street.1

Rule 12.2 deals with reports where nobody visits. It says a desktop “does not meet the requirements of Rules 10 and 11 and is not an IVS compliant valuation as it can only result in an indicative value”.1 The International Valuation Standards go further for software: “No model without the valuer applying professional judgement, for example an automated valuation model (AVM), can produce an IVS-compliant valuation.”2 The API’s own CGT guidance puts it plainly: automated estimates “involve no valuer at all and are not valuation reports”.3

The ATO looks at it from a different angle. For tax purposes, “the acceptability of a valuation usually depends on the valuation process undertaken rather than who conducted it”, though “valuations undertaken by professional valuers are more credible than those provided by someone who isn’t a professional valuer”.45 Neither of the ATO’s two valuation documents uses the words desktop, kerbside, drive-by or automated. So the API rules tell you what each report is; the ATO’s guidance tells you what it expects a tax valuation to contain and how it was arrived at.

Property valuation reports side by side

The table below sets out each common type of report. The fourth column is the one that matters most: whether the report counts as a valuation under API rules.

Report typeWho prepares or signsInspectionA valuation under API rules?What the ATO saysFrom ValueEdge?Price incl. GST
Automated estimateA data model. No valuerNoneNo. IVS 105: no model alone can produce a valuationSMSF accounts: online reports acceptable if they list the comparable sales relied onYes: Market value estimate. Not a valuation$195
Real estate agent appraisalA real estate agentUsuallyNoSMSF accounts: acceptable if comparable sales are listed. Penalty example in a related-party saleNoUsually free from agents
Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection)A Certified Practising ValuerNoneNo. Indicative value only (Rule 12.2)Not mentionedYes. Not for CGT cost base or court$249
Kerbside (drive-by) valuationThe valuer who inspectsOutside only, from the streetYes, with the limited inspection disclosedNot mentionedNoNot offered
Inspected (full) valuationThe valuer who inspectsFull, inside and outYesProfessional valuations "are more credible"Yes. Valuation, signed by a CPV$550 ($495 early bird)
Retrospective valuationA valuerAs neededYes, where inspectedThe report must say it is retrospectiveYes, as a specialist valuationQuoted, from $650
Sworn or court valuationAn expert valuerUsually fullYesCourt rules apply, not ATO guidanceYes, as a specialist valuationQuoted, from $650

Sources: API Rules 11.2 and 12.21; IVS 1052; API CGT guidance3; ATO market valuation guidance45; ATO SMSF valuation guide6.

Each type in brief

Market value estimate (not a valuation)

An estimate is a figure produced by a model from sales data. No valuer forms an opinion and nobody inspects the property. The free figures on property portals are estimates, and so is ours.

Our Market value estimate costs $195 and is checked by our staff before it is sent, but it is not a valuation. It suits pre-sale checks and SMSF updates between full valuations. The ATO’s SMSF guide says reports from “online services” are acceptable for a fund’s annual accounts, provided the report lists the comparable sales relied on, and that one item of evidence alone is generally not enough.6 An estimate is not suitable for a CGT cost base, stamp duty, family law or court.

Real estate agent appraisal

An appraisal is an agent’s opinion of the price a property might sell for, usually given free and often in the hope of winning the listing. It is not a valuation.

The ATO accepts agent appraisals as evidence for SMSF annual accounts when they list the comparable sales relied on.6 For tax events the picture is less comfortable. One of the ATO’s own penalty examples involves an appraisal from the taxpayer’s husband’s agency, used to set the price in a family sale: it drew an intentional-disregard penalty.5 The API says agent appraisals will not meet the ATO’s expectation of independence.3 More on this in appraisal vs valuation.

Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection)

A desktop report is prepared from sales evidence, title records, plans, aerial and street imagery and any photos the owner supplies, without anyone visiting. Ours is called the Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection). A Certified Practising Valuer reviews the evidence, forms their own opinion and signs it.

Under API rules it provides an indicative value, not a market valuation, and the report says so.1 The API’s guidance adds that an indicative value “is not and should not be construed to represent the Valuer’s opinion as to the market value”.7 Our desktop costs $249 and suits SMSF reporting and pre-sale checks. It is not suitable for the 1 July 2027 CGT cost base or for court.

Kerbside (drive-by) valuation

In a kerbside valuation the valuer inspects the property from the street but does not go inside. API rules count it as a valuation, under Rule 11.2(c), but the report must disclose the limited inspection and “the effect” it has on the opinion of value (Rule 11.4).1 The API also warns that a limited inspection may mean the value given does not meet the definition of market value.8

ValueEdge does not offer kerbside reports. We offer the desktop where an inspection is not needed, and the full inspection where it is.

Inspected (full) valuation

In an inspected valuation, often called a full valuation, the valuer who signs inspects the property inside and out: measuring, photographing and noting its condition and improvements before analysing sales evidence. The API recommends this kind of report “for a value the tax system relies on”.3

Our Inspected valuation costs $550, or $495 if booked before the early-bird closing date [TBC: early-bird closing date]. It is the report we offer for the 1 July 2027 CGT cost base and for larger SMSF holdings. For the reset, nothing is valued before 1 July 2027: you can reserve a place and a price now, and the valuation is prepared afterwards.

Retrospective valuation

A retrospective valuation gives the market value at a past date: when you bought, inherited or first rented out a property, for example. The ATO’s list of what a valuation report should contain includes stating whether it is a retrospective valuation, and the ATO warns against relying on information from after the valuation date.45 The API says a valuation prepared close to 1 July 2027, “ideally three to four months post 1 July 2027, and at most within two years”, is more defensible than one prepared years later.3

We prepare retrospective valuations as specialist work, quoted from $650. See retrospective property valuation.

Sworn valuation

“Sworn valuation” usually means a valuation prepared as evidence for a court. In family law property cases, the Family Law Rules say expert evidence is given by a single expert witness “if practicable”, and the expert’s duty to the court prevails over any duty to whoever pays them. The report must state its reasons, method, assumptions and the expert’s qualifications.9

This is specialist work, quoted from $650. See family law property valuation.

Bank valuation

A bank valuation is prepared for the lender, to support its lending decision, and it is the lender’s report rather than yours. If you want to use one for another purpose, ask the lender whether you can have a copy and check that its date, scope and purpose suit what you need it for. For tax, the ATO looks at the process behind any valuation, not its label.5

Which report for which purpose

The right report depends on what the value is for. The “usually enough” column summarises what the ATO, the API, the courts and revenue offices say; where a line is our reading rather than a published rule, it says so.

PurposeWhat is usually enoughOur reportNot suitable
1 July 2027 CGT resetATO guidance not yet published. The API recommends a comprehensive inspectionInspected valuation, prepared after 1 July 2027Estimate, desktop
Other CGT events (sale, gift, inheritance, first rented)A professional valuer's report as at the event dateInspected valuation for a current date; specialist valuation for a past dateEstimate, desktop
SMSF annual accountsA report listing comparable sales plus another item of evidence; an independent valuer where the property is a large share of the fund or complexDesktop, or inspected for larger holdingsEstimate as the only evidence
Division 296 (end of 30 June 2026)No separate standard: the SMSF guide appliesSpecialist valuation as at 30 June 2026, quotedEstimate
Family lawA full inspection valuation addressed to the court by a single expert (our reading of the rules)Specialist valuation, quotedEstimate, desktop, appraisal
Deceased estateA valuation as at the date of deathSpecialist valuation, quotedEstimate
Stamp duty on a family or related-party transferA full valuation by a valuer who meets that state's definitionInspected or specialist valuation, quotedEstimate; agent appraisal in Victoria
InsuranceA rebuild cost estimate, not market valueNot offeredAny market valuation
Thinking of selling or buyingNo legal requirement. A desktop or estimate for a sense-check (our reading)Estimate or desktopNothing ruled out

Sources: API CGT guidance3; ATO newsroom, 19 October 202610; ATO market valuation guidance45; ATO SMSF guide6; ATO Division 296 page17; Family Law Rules9; ATO inherited assets18; Revenue NSW19; SRO Victoria20; Moneysmart2122.

Three points sit behind that table.

A valuation is optional for the 1 July 2027 reset. The alternative is the apportionment formula, which is still a draft. The choice is made when you lodge the return for the year you sell, not by 30 June 2027. Whether a valuation or the formula suits you is a question for your registered tax agent. More on the reset in the 1 July 2027 CGT valuation guide.

SMSF trustees have more room. The ATO does not require a qualified independent valuer every year, but says trustees should consider one where a property is a significant share of the fund or complex to value.6 Your auditor decides whether the evidence is sufficient. See SMSF property valuation.

Insurance is a different question. Moneysmart warns against “using market value instead of rebuild cost”, because market value includes the land.21 A market valuation is the wrong report for setting a sum insured.

Who may sign a valuation

Who may value land depends on the state, and no “ATO-approved valuer” exists for CGT. The ATO describes a real property valuer as someone registered or licensed under state law where that applies.5

  • Queensland requires registration with the Valuers Registration Board of Queensland. Holding yourself out as a registered valuer without registration is an offence.11
  • Western Australia requires a land valuer’s licence to carry on business or take a fee as a valuer of land.12
  • South Australia and Tasmania keep no register, but a person must hold prescribed qualifications to carry on business as a land valuer.1314
  • New South Wales repealed its valuer registration law with effect from 1 March 2016.15
  • Victoria, the ACT and the Northern Territory: we found no valuer licensing law, but we could not positively confirm that none exists.

“Registered valuer” is a legal term only in Queensland. Elsewhere, look for the credential the valuer actually holds. The most common is the API’s Certified Practising Valuer (CPV) certification, which requires an accredited course, two years’ valuation experience in the past four, a report review and an interview.16

Every ValueEdge valuation is signed by a CPV who is licensed or registered for that state where the state requires it. At launch we work in NSW only. Read more about who signs our reports and our independence policy.

Next steps

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a desktop and a kerbside valuation?

A desktop involves no physical inspection; under API rules it gives an "indicative value" and is not a valuation. A kerbside involves the valuer inspecting from the street. API rules treat it as a valuation with a limited inspection, which must be disclosed with its likely effect on the value. ValueEdge does not offer kerbside reports.

Is an online property estimate a valuation?

No. Under the International Valuation Standards, no model can produce a compliant valuation without a valuer applying professional judgement. The API says automated estimates "involve no valuer at all and are not valuation reports". The ATO accepts online reports for SMSF annual accounts if they list the comparable sales relied on.

Must the valuer who signs have inspected the property?

Under API rules, a valuation requires physical inspection by the "Primary Valuer", who takes responsibility for it. Staff without RPV certification can only assist and must not sign as a valuer. An RPV's valuation generally needs review and countersigning by a CPV, except kerbside assessments under the API's restricted assessment memorandum.

Will the API accept a video or virtual inspection?

Not as a "valuation" on current wording. API Rule 11.2 lists comprehensive, limited on-site or kerbside physical inspections by the Primary Valuer. The API says reports without "any form of physical inspection" are desktops, also called "virtual inspection reports", and give an indicative value only.

Do valuers need a licence in Australia?

It depends on the state. Queensland requires registration with the Valuers Registration Board and WA requires a land valuer's licence. South Australia and Tasmania have no register but require prescribed qualifications to carry on business as a land valuer. NSW repealed registration in 2016. No licensing law was found for Victoria, the ACT or the NT.

Why do two valuations of the same house differ?

Usually because something about them differs: the valuation date, the sales chosen as evidence, whether the valuer inspected, or the purpose. The ATO lists common problems with valuations, including poor comparable sales, unsupported adjustments and relying on information from after the valuation date. A full report sets out its evidence and method, so you can see where two figures part ways.

Sources

  1. Rules of Professional Conduct (effective 1 August 2025) — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  2. International Valuation Standards (effective 31 January 2025), IVS 105 — International Valuation Standards Council. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  3. The CGT Changes and Property Valuations: What you need to know — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  4. Market valuation of assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  5. Market valuation for tax purposes — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  6. Guide to valuing SMSF assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  7. Desktop Process is... (Standards Series No. 4) — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  8. Valuations with Limited or No Physical Inspection by a Valuer — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  9. Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021, Part 7.1 — Federal Register of Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  10. CGT reform – guidance and market valuations — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  11. Valuers Registration Act 1992 (Qld) — Queensland Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  12. Land Valuers Licensing Act 1978 (WA) — Western Australian Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  13. Land Valuers Act 1994 (SA) — South Australian Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  14. Land Valuers Act 2001 (Tas) — Tasmanian Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  15. Ruling DUT 044v2 — Revenue NSW. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  16. Certified Practising Valuer (CPV) certification — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  17. About Division 296 tax for SMSFs — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  18. How CGT applies to inherited assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  19. Determining dutiable value — Revenue NSW. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  20. Valuation of land for duty purposes — State Revenue Office Victoria. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  21. Home underinsurance — ASIC Moneysmart. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  22. Buying a house — ASIC Moneysmart. Accessed 17/11/2026.

Send an enquiry

Anything that helps: the date the value is needed for, the property type, any deadline from a court or an auditor.

We reply within [TBC: enquiry response time — ENQUIRY_RESPONSE_TIME]. Nothing is charged by sending this form.

Preview only. Your request is recorded locally; no email is sent.