Draft for review, not published

Desktop or inspected valuation: which do you need?

Direct answer

A Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) is prepared from records and sales data without anyone visiting; under API rules it gives an indicative value, not a market valuation. An inspected valuation means the signing valuer inspects the property in person. For the 1 July 2027 CGT cost base, use an inspected valuation; court work is a specialist valuation. A desktop can suit SMSF annual reporting and pre-sale checks.

Where the law stands

As at
ATO valuation guidance for the reset
pendingOn 19 October 2026 the ATO promised guidance on valuation methods, the types of professional to consider and the records required. Not published as at 17 November 2026.Source ·

This comparison is part of our guide to property valuation reports. Both reports are signed by a Certified Practising Valuer (CPV). The difference is the inspection, and that difference decides what each report can be used for.

Side by side

Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection)Inspected valuation
Product labelSigned by a CPV · indicative value under API rulesValuation, signed by a CPV
Who signsA CPVThe CPV who inspects
InspectionNoneFull, inside and out, in person
Under API rulesIndicative value, not a valuation (Rule 12.2)A valuation (Rule 11.2)
EvidenceSales data, title, plans, imagery, owner photosThe same, plus the inspection, measurements and photos
1 July 2027 CGT cost baseNoYes
Other CGT events and past datesNot offered for CGT. Ask for a quoteYes (past dates as a specialist valuation)
SMSF annual accountsYes, as a report listing comparable sales. Larger or complex holdings may need an inspectionYes
Court and family lawNoSpecialist valuation, quoted from $650
Stamp dutyCheck your state's rulesYes, by a valuer meeting the state's definition
Price incl. GST$249$550 ($495 early bird for 1 July 2027 reservations)

Sources: API Rules 11.2 and 12.21; API CGT guidance2; ATO SMSF guide8; ATO market valuation guidance6.

What a desktop is under API rules

A desktop is a report prepared with no physical inspection of any kind. Under the Australian Property Institute’s Rule 12.2, a desktop “does not meet the requirements of Rules 10 and 11 and is not an IVS compliant valuation as it can only result in an indicative value”.1 The API’s CGT guidance describes it as “no inspection; an indicative value only, not a valuation report”.2

Desktops go by other names too: desktop assessment, indicative assessment, “virtual inspection report” and “valuer-assisted AVM”.3 A report built on someone else’s photos or a video walk-through is still a desktop, because the valuer did not physically inspect.

Our Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) is reviewed and signed by a CPV, who forms their own opinion from the evidence. The report states that it is a desktop under API rules and gives an indicative value.

What an inspected valuation is

An inspected valuation is one where the valuer who signs has physically inspected the property. API Rule 11.2 says a valuation requires a physical inspection by the Primary Valuer, the person who takes responsibility for the opinion; staff who are not certified valuers may assist but cannot sign as the valuer.1

Our Inspected valuation is a full internal and external inspection by the CPV who signs. The valuer measures, photographs and notes the property’s condition and improvements, then analyses sales evidence and arrives at a single value.

Where kerbside fits

A kerbside (drive-by) valuation sits between the two. The valuer inspects from the street but does not go inside. API rules count it as a valuation under Rule 11.2(c), but the report must disclose the limited inspection and “the effect” it has on the opinion (Rule 11.4).1 The API also warns that a limited inspection may mean the value does not meet the definition of market value.4

ValueEdge does not offer kerbside reports.

Which one for which purpose

PurposeUsually suitableNot suitableWhy
1 July 2027 CGT cost baseInspected valuationDesktop; estimatesThe API recommends a comprehensive inspection for tax. The ATO has not yet said what it will accept
SMSF annual accountsDesktop or inspectedAn estimate alone, if it does not list comparable salesATO: "Generally, it is not sufficient for valuations to be based on only one item of evidence"
Family lawSpecialist inspected valuation, as a single expertDesktopFamily Law Rules: single expert where practicable; duty to the court
Pre-sale checkEstimate or desktop—No legal requirement
Stamp dutyInspected, by a valuer meeting that state's definitionAgent appraisal in VictoriaRevenue offices set who may value

Sources: API CGT guidance2; ATO newsroom, 19 October 20267; ATO SMSF guide8; Family Law Rules rr 7.02, 7.189; Moneysmart10; Revenue NSW11; SRO Victoria12.

For SMSF accounts, the deciding factor is often the size of the holding. The ATO says trustees should consider a qualified independent valuer where a property “represents a significant proportion of the fund’s value” or is complex.8 Your auditor decides what is sufficient. See SMSF property valuation. For court work, see family law property valuation.

What the ATO says

The ATO has not said anything about desktops specifically. Its two valuation documents do not use the words desktop, kerbside or drive-by.56 Here is what it does say, and what it has left open.

  • Process over person. “For tax purposes, the acceptability of a valuation usually depends on the valuation process undertaken rather than who conducted it.”6
  • Professionals carry more weight. “Valuations undertaken by professional valuers are more credible than those provided by someone who isn’t a professional valuer.”5
  • Inspection where required. Evidence is gathered “by means such as inspection (as required), enquiry, computation and analysis”.6
  • Penalty protection is not addressed for desktops. The ATO says that generally, if you engage and properly instruct a professional valuer, you won’t be liable for penalties if the valuation is later found deficient.5 Whether that extends to a report prepared without an inspection, it has not said.
  • The reset is not yet covered. The ATO has not published what kind of valuation it will accept for the 1 July 2027 reset. It promised guidance on the types of professional to consider and the records required on 19 October 2026.7 Follow it on our ATO guidance tracker.

So the professional body’s position is clear, and the ATO’s is not yet. For a value the tax system will rely on, the API recommends a comprehensive inspection.2

When the inspection changes the value

An inspection matters most where the property differs from what the records say. A valuer working from data cannot see:

  • a recent renovation, new kitchen or bathroom, or an extension not yet on the plans
  • the condition of the property: well kept, tired, or in need of repair
  • defects such as damp, cracking or water damage
  • views, outlook, noise or aspect that the photos do not show
  • an unusual layout, granny flat or outbuilding.

This list is our reading of what records leave out, not a published rule. If any of it applies to your property, the difference between the two reports is more than a matter of price. A recent renovation is the most common example: a desktop can only reflect it as far as the plans, imagery and your photos show it.

Price

Report Our price incl. GST Published market range, November 2026
Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) $249 About $119 to $325 (signed desktop, standard home)
Inspected valuation $550; $495 early bird for 1 July 2027 reservations booked before [TBC: early-bird closing date] About $399 to $646 (full inspection, standard home)

Market ranges are providers’ own published entry prices, checked 17 November 2026; ranges, not quotes. Consumer guides quote free to $200 for desktop and automated reports and $300 to $600 for a full residential valuation.1314 Method and detail in our property valuation cost guide; every ValueEdge price is on our pricing page.

Your next step

Frequently asked questions

Is a desktop valuation acceptable for CGT?

The ATO's CGT guidance doesn't mention desktop reports either way, and it has not yet said what it will accept for the 1 July 2027 reset. The Australian Property Institute says a desktop, such as our Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection), gives an "indicative value" only and is "not a valuation report", and it recommends a comprehensive inspection for tax. For SMSF annual accounts, the ATO accepts online and agent reports that list comparable sales.

What is the difference between a desktop and a kerbside valuation?

A desktop involves no physical inspection; under API rules it gives an "indicative value" and is not a valuation. A kerbside involves the valuer inspecting from the street. API rules treat it as a valuation with a limited inspection, which must be disclosed with its likely effect on the value. ValueEdge does not offer kerbside reports.

Must the valuer who signs have inspected the property?

Under API rules, a valuation requires physical inspection by the "Primary Valuer", who takes responsibility for it. Staff without RPV certification can only assist and must not sign as a valuer. An RPV's valuation generally needs review and countersigning by a CPV, except kerbside assessments under the API's restricted assessment memorandum.

Will the API accept a video or virtual inspection?

Not as a "valuation" on current wording. API Rule 11.2 lists comprehensive, limited on-site or kerbside physical inspections by the Primary Valuer. The API says reports without "any form of physical inspection" are desktops, also called "virtual inspection reports", and give an indicative value only.

Is a bank desktop valuation the same thing?

Not necessarily. A bank orders a valuation for its own lending decision, on its own instructions, and the report is the lender's. It may be a desktop, a kerbside or a full inspection. Our desktop is prepared for the purpose you tell us and states that it is a desktop under API rules. If you hope to reuse a bank's report, ask the lender first.

Why do two valuations of the same house differ?

Usually because something about them differs: the valuation date, the sales chosen as evidence, whether the valuer inspected, or the purpose. The ATO lists common problems with valuations, including poor comparable sales, unsupported adjustments and relying on information from after the valuation date. A full report sets out its evidence and method, so you can see where two figures part ways.

Sources

  1. Rules of Professional Conduct (effective 1 August 2025) — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  2. The CGT Changes and Property Valuations: What you need to know — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  3. Desktop Process is... (Standards Series No. 4) — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  4. Valuations with Limited or No Physical Inspection by a Valuer — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  5. Market valuation of assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  6. Market valuation for tax purposes — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  7. CGT reform – guidance and market valuations — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  8. Guide to valuing SMSF assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  9. Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021, Part 7.1 — Federal Register of Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  10. Buying a house — ASIC Moneysmart. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  11. Determining dutiable value — Revenue NSW. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  12. Valuation of land for duty purposes — State Revenue Office Victoria. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  13. Property valuation cost guide — Mozo. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  14. Free property valuations — Finder. Accessed 17/11/2026.