Draft for review, not published

Property valuations for capital gains tax: when you need one and what the ATO expects

Direct answer

You need a market valuation for capital gains tax when the law uses market value instead of what you paid or received: some inherited property, a home first rented out, gifts and family transfers, missing records, and the 1 July 2027 reset. The ATO judges the valuation process rather than who did it, but says professional valuations are more credible and generally protect you from penalties if you instruct the valuer properly.

What “market value” means for tax

Market value is what a property would sell for on the open market at a particular date. The ATO describes it as “the estimated monetary worth of an asset on the open market at a particular time”, based on its most valuable use and the price a willing buyer and a willing seller would agree in an arm’s length deal.1

The tax law does not define it fully. The ATO says the definition in section 995-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 “does not provide a meaning to be applied in all contexts”, and that case law and international valuation principles are “principally relevant”.2

Two consequences follow for any CGT valuation:

  • It must be at the date the law sets. That might be a date of death, the day a home was first rented, or just before 1 July 2027. The ATO says a valuation must be for “a date specified by the legislation and a prospective assessment will not be considered reasonable or acceptable”.2
  • It must rest on evidence available at that date. Relying on information from after the valuation date is one of the common problems the ATO lists.2

Need a valuation now? Request a quote. Valuing for 1 July 2027? Reserve a place.

When a CGT event needs a market value

Most of the time, CGT uses what you actually paid and received. Market value replaces those figures only where the law says so. These are the property situations where it does.

EventDate valuedLaw (ITAA 1997)Usually enoughMore detail
1 July 2027 resetJust before 1 July 2027ss 112-155, 112-165, 112-175A valuation or the formula (the formula is a draft); the API recommends a comprehensive inspectionThe 1 July 2027 CGT valuation
Inherited pre-CGT asset, or the deceased's main residenceDate of deaths 128-15(4)A retrospective date-of-death valuationDeceased estate guide (planned)
Home first rented out after 20 August 1996First income uses 118-192A retrospective valuation as at first rentalGuide planned
Six-year rule exceededFirst rentals 118-145A valuation dated at first rental (our inference)Guide planned
Gift of propertyTransfer datess 116-30(1), 112-20A professional valuationGuide planned
Related-party sale below or above market valueTransfer dates 116-30(2)(b)An independent valuation; avoid connected agentsGuide planned
Missing purchase recordsAcquisition dates 121-20A professional valuer's retrospective reportRetrospective property valuation
Improvements to pre-CGT propertyThe relevant dates 108-70A valuer, or a reasonable documented estimatePre-CGT guide (planned)
Small business maximum net asset value testJust before the CGT events 152-15 ($6 million, not indexed)A professional valuationGuide planned
Foreign resident withholding with a non-arm's-length priceContractForeign resident capital gains withholding rulesA "professional valuer" (ATO wording)Guide planned
Relationship breakdown rolloverNot applicableSubdivision 126-AUsually no CGT valuation for the transfer itselfFamily law property valuation

Sources for the table, row by row: the reset;36 inherited property;1211 home first rented;1314 six-year rule;1516 gifts and related-party transfers;1718192 missing records;910 pre-CGT improvements;25 small business;2324 foreign residents;22 relationship breakdown.2021

Detailed pages: the 1 July 2027 CGT valuation, retrospective property valuation and family law property valuation. Guides to each of the other events are being written.

A few points from the table that people often miss:

  • Inherited property usually carries over the deceased’s cost base. Market value at the date of death applies instead for property the deceased acquired before 20 September 1985, and for a home that was their main residence just before death and not producing income.12 The ATO says that where you need that value and the executor has not had the asset valued, you should “get your own valuation”.11
  • A home first rented out. The ATO says “You must get a market valuation of your home when you first start using it for rental or business, if this was after 20 August 1996”, though “you can arrange a valuation later if necessary”.14
  • Missing records. You must keep CGT records until five years after it becomes certain no further CGT event can happen for which they are relevant.9 Where records are missing, for example for a gifted asset, the ATO suggests asking “a professional valuer to tell you what the market value would have been”.10

Who can prepare it

For most CGT purposes, the ATO looks at how the valuation was done rather than who did it. In its words, “the acceptability of a valuation usually depends on the valuation process undertaken rather than who conducted it”.2 The exceptions are the GST margin scheme and the Cultural Gifts Program, neither of which applies here.

That does not mean any figure will do. The ATO also says “Valuations undertaken by professional valuers are more credible than those provided by someone who isn’t a professional valuer”.1 Its guide describes a real property valuer as “a person who is registered or licenced to carry out real property valuations under the relevant State, Territory or Commonwealth legislation”.2

The state rules differ:

State or territory Rule for land valuers
Queensland Registration with the Valuers Registration Board of Queensland26
Western Australia A land valuer’s licence27
South Australia No register, but prescribed qualifications are needed to carry on business as a land valuer28
Tasmania No register, but prescribed qualifications are needed29
New South Wales Registration was repealed from 1 March 201630
Victoria, ACT, Northern Territory No valuer licensing law found (we could not positively confirm there is none)

There is no ATO list of approved valuers for CGT. “Registered valuer” has a legal meaning only in Queensland.

Who signs our reports. Every ValueEdge valuation is signed by an Australian Property Institute Certified Practising Valuer (CPV), registered or licensed for that state where the law requires it. At launch we work in NSW only.

What the ATO expects in the report

The ATO’s guide lists what a valuation report for tax should contain “at a minimum”. This is that list:2

  1. The purpose of the valuation, including the tax provision it is for.
  2. The scope of the work and any limitations.
  3. Details of the asset.
  4. The information sources, facts and assumptions relied on.
  5. The standards followed, for example International Valuation Standards.
  6. The valuation date, stating if it is a retrospective valuation.
  7. The date of inspection, if there was one.
  8. The definition of value used.
  9. The approach and method, with reasons and cross-checks.
  10. Records sufficient for the valuation to be replicated.
  11. Any use of other experts.
  12. Any use of previous valuations.
  13. An explanation of material differences from historical cost and earlier valuations.
  14. A specific value, explaining the choice within any range.
  15. Risks and disclaimers.
  16. The terms of engagement and instructions.
  17. The valuer’s identity, status and qualifications.
  18. A declaration of independence and any conflicts, and the date the report was issued.

The ATO also recommends “(where possible) a secondary or cross-check methodology”, and evidence gathered “by means such as inspection (as required), enquiry, computation and analysis”.2 The ATO’s shorter web page has a summary version of the list.1

Our reports are prepared by a qualified, independent valuer in line with the ATO’s published market valuation guidance.12 You can see the layout on our sample report page.

Properly instructing a valuer

The ATO expects you to be able to show that you instructed the valuer properly. It lists six things:1

  1. You set out the scope and purpose of the valuation.
  2. You acknowledged the valuer’s independence.
  3. You recognised the valuer can refuse to report without the information they need.
  4. You gave access to the premises and records.
  5. You gave all the help necessary.
  6. You stated that the fee does not depend on the outcome.

This is usually done in a written request or engagement letter.2 Ours sets out the scope and purpose, acknowledges the valuer’s independence and states that the fee does not depend on the value.

Penalty protection: what it does and doesn’t cover

The ATO’s position is: “Generally, if you engage and properly instruct a professional valuer, you won’t be liable for penalties if we find the professional valuation is deficient.”1 Relying in good faith on a professional valuation of real property “is consistent with taking reasonable care, even if the advice later proves to be deficient”.2

It has limits. Penalties can still apply if:2

  • you did not give the valuer correct information
  • you or your agent “should reasonably have known the value was incorrect”
  • the method relies on “an unsettled interpretation of a tax or superannuation provision or unclear facts”.

Even where penalties don’t apply, the ATO can still change the value and the tax, and interest charges can still apply.2 The ATO says “The onus for providing a replicable and defensible valuation remains with you even when a professional is engaged.”2

This is administrative guidance using the word “Generally”. It is not a statutory safe harbour. The ATO has also not said whether a desktop report from a professional valuer, with no inspection, attracts the same protection.

When the ATO is more likely to review

The ATO says “The likelihood of having a valuation reviewed is greater where the asset’s value is high or the methodology used is contentious.”2

The common problems it lists include poor comparable sales, unsupported inputs, “reliance on post-valuation date information”, averaging, and missing assumptions.2

Two of its published examples are worth knowing:2

  • A self-valuation with poor comparables. A company valued its own properties for the small business net asset test using dissimilar sales. The ATO found the value understated by 25% and applied a penalty for recklessness.
  • A non-independent agent appraisal. In a related-party sale, a taxpayer relied on an appraisal from her husband’s real estate agency. The ATO applied a penalty for intentional disregard.

Which report suits a CGT event

For a figure that goes into a cost base or capital proceeds, use a valuation by a qualified valuer, usually with an inspection. Our Inspected valuation (valuation, signed by a CPV) and Specialist valuation (valuation, signed by a CPV, for retrospective, estate, family law and complex work) are the reports we offer for CGT.

Other reports have different status:

  • Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection). A CPV values the property from records and data, with no inspection. Under Australian Property Institute rules it provides an indicative value and “is not an IVS compliant valuation” (Rule 12.2).7 Ours is not for a CGT cost base or court; it suits SMSF reporting and pre-sale checks.
  • Estimates (not a valuation). No model can produce a compliant valuation without a valuer’s judgement, under International Valuation Standards.8 The API says automated estimates “involve no valuer at all and are not valuation reports”.6
  • Agent appraisals (not a valuation). The API says agent appraisals will not meet the ATO’s independence requirement for tax.6 The ATO’s intentional-disregard example above involved one.

For SMSF annual accounts the rules are looser: the ATO accepts online and agent reports that list the comparable sales relied on.33 That is a different purpose from setting a CGT cost base.

See desktop versus inspected valuations, appraisal versus valuation and our guide to valuation types.

The 1 July 2027 reset

From 1 July 2027 there is a new and very common reason for a CGT valuation. Resident individuals and trusts holding property at the end of 30 June 2027 are treated as selling and buying it back at its market value just before 1 July 2027.3 A valuation is optional: the alternative is an apportionment formula, still in draft.31 The valuation cannot be prepared before 1 July 2027, because the ATO says it “can’t be forward-looking”.5

Where the law stands

As at
The CGT change
finalTreasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026 passed 25 June 2026, law from 26 June 2026; applies from 1 July 2027.Source ·
Apportionment formula
draftExposure-draft Determination released 4 August 2026; consultation closed 21 August 2026; not made.Source ·
ATO valuation guidance for the reset
pendingPromised 19 October 2026 (types of professional, methods, records); not published.Source ·

Read the 1 July 2027 CGT valuation for the detail, valuation or formula for the choice, and the ATO guidance tracker for what the ATO has published.4 Only the 1 July 2027 reset has a formula alternative; the other events on this page need a market value. Which method to use for the reset is a question for a registered tax agent: the Tax Practitioners Board says advising on a person’s tax position for a fee needs registration, and we do not give that advice.32

Can I ask the ATO to confirm a value?

Yes, with limits. You can apply for a private ruling asking the ATO to value an asset or to confirm your valuation, and it may pass on its valuer’s fee. It will not give a ruling on “the market value applicable for a future event”.2

The ATO also offers joint valuations, where you and the ATO share the cost of one valuer.2

Prices

Our inspected valuation is $550 including GST. Specialist valuations, including retrospective and date-of-death work, are quoted from $650 including GST. Each report below carries its label, so you can see which are valuations and which are not.

Report option

Market value estimate

Not a valuation

$195 incl. GST

Prepared by
Data model, checked by staff
Inspection
None
Used for
Pre-sale checks; SMSF updates between full valuations
Not suitable for
CGT cost base, court or a signed valuation
Order or enquire

Planned

CGT market value estimate

Not a valuation

$319 incl. GST

Prepared by
Data model, checked by staff
Inspection
None
Used for
1 July 2027 cost base only if tax advice confirms it is accepted
Not suitable for
Not for sale while the ATO position is unknown

On hold until the ATO says what it will accept for the reset.

Report option

Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection)

Signed by a CPV · indicative value under API rules

$249 incl. GST

Prepared by
A CPV values from records and data, then signs
Inspection
None
Used for
SMSF reporting; pre-sale checks. Provides an indicative value under API rules
Not suitable for
CGT cost base or court
Order or enquire

For the 2027 reset

Inspected valuation

Valuation, signed by a CPV

$550 incl. GST

Early bird $495 incl. GST · if reserved before [TBC: early-bird closing date]

Prepared by
The signing CPV inspects in person
Inspection
Full internal
Used for
1 July 2027 CGT cost base; larger SMSF holdings
Not suitable for
Building or pest assessment
Reserve a 1 July 2027 valuation

Report option

Specialist valuation

Valuation, signed by a CPV

From $650 incl. GST

Prepared by
A CPV with relevant experience
Inspection
Usually
Used for
Retrospective, family law, estate, commercial and property over $3 million
Not suitable for
Scope must be agreed before ordering
Request a quote

The pricing page has full details and published market ranges, and our guide to what a property valuation costs explains what changes the price.

Frequently asked questions

Does the ATO require a registered valuer?

Not for most CGT purposes. The ATO says acceptability "usually depends on the valuation process undertaken rather than who conducted it", though professional valuations "are more credible". Its guide describes a real property valuer as someone registered or licensed under state law where that applies, naming Queensland registration and WA licensing.

Is there an "ATO-approved" valuer?

No such status exists for CGT valuations. The ATO says acceptability "usually depends on the valuation process undertaken rather than who conducted it", and names "approved valuers" only for the Cultural Gifts Program. For real property it describes a valuer registered or licensed under state law where that applies.

What should a valuation report for tax include?

At a minimum the ATO expects the purpose and tax provision, scope, asset details, information and assumptions relied on, standards applied, valuation date (flagged if retrospective), inspection date if any, definition of value, method and cross-check, records to replicate the work, a single value, engagement terms, the valuer's identity and qualifications, an independence declaration and the issue date.

Will a professional valuation protect me from ATO penalties?

Generally, yes, if you engage and properly instruct a professional valuer: the ATO says you "won't be liable for penalties" if the valuation is later found deficient. Protection is lost if you gave wrong information, should reasonably have known the value was wrong, or the method relied on unsettled law or unclear facts. Extra tax and interest can still apply.

Can I use a real estate agent's appraisal for CGT?

The ATO doesn't ban it, but warns about using unqualified valuers, and one of its penalty examples involved a non-independent agent appraisal in a family sale. The Australian Property Institute says agent appraisals won't meet the ATO's independence requirement. For SMSF annual accounts the ATO accepts agent appraisals that list comparable sales.

Is a desktop valuation acceptable for CGT?

The ATO's CGT guidance doesn't mention desktops either way. The Australian Property Institute says a desktop (no inspection) produces only an "indicative value" that is "not a valuation report", and recommends a comprehensive inspection for tax. Our own desktop valuation is not offered for a CGT cost base.

Can I value the property myself?

The ATO judges the process rather than the person, so a self-valuation is not ruled out. It must still be objective, supported by evidence and replicable. One ATO example describes a taxpayer who valued its own properties using poor comparable sales, understated value by 25% and was penalised for recklessness. The ATO says professional valuations are more credible.

Can a valuer tell me whether to use the valuation or the formula?

Generally no, unless they are a registered tax agent. The Tax Practitioners Board says a valuer who only provides a valuation is not providing a tax agent service, but advising a person on their tax position for a fee needs registration. Ask a registered tax agent which method suits you.

Can I reset my cost base just by getting a valuation?

No. A valuation changes nothing on its own. Market value becomes part of a cost base only where the law says so: for example the 1 July 2027 reset, some inherited property, a home first rented out after 20 August 1996, or a gift or non-arm's-length transfer. Otherwise your cost base is what you actually paid. Your tax agent can confirm which rule applies.

Sources

  1. Market valuation of assets (QC 66067) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  2. Market valuation for tax purposes (legal database guide, current at February 2025) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  3. Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026 (No. 49, 2026), as made — Federal Register of Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  4. Capital gains tax reform (QC 108170) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  5. CGT reform: guidance and market valuations (QC 108200) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  6. The CGT Changes and Property Valuations: What you need to know — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  7. API Rules of Professional Conduct, effective 1 August 2025 — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  8. International Valuation Standards (effective 31 January 2025), IVS 105 — International Valuation Standards Council (third-party hosted copy). Accessed 17/11/2026.
  9. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, sections 121-20 and 121-25 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  10. Keeping records for property (QC 66027) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  11. How CGT applies to inherited assets (QC 69713) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  12. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 128-15 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  13. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 118-192 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  14. Using your home for rental or business (QC 66033) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  15. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 118-145 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  16. Treating former home as main residence (QC 66030) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  17. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 116-30 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  18. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 112-20 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  19. Transferring property to family or friends (QC 66041) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  20. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 126-5 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  21. When the relationship breakdown rollover applies (QC 66064) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  22. Foreign resident capital gains withholding overview (QC 48972) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  23. Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, section 152-15 — Australian Taxation Office legal database. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  24. Maximum net asset value test (QC 52270) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  25. Property improvements and additions (QC 66043) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  26. Valuers Registration Act 1992 (Qld) — Queensland Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  27. Land Valuers Licensing Act 1978 (WA) — Western Australian Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  28. Land Valuers Act 1994 (SA) — South Australian Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  29. Land Valuers Act 2001 (Tas) — Tasmanian Legislation. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  30. Revenue Ruling DUT 044v2 — Revenue NSW. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  31. Exposure draft, Income Tax Assessment (Method for Apportioning Capital Gains and Capital Losses) Determination 2026 — The Treasury. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  32. Do valuers need to register as tax agents? (TPB(I) 16/2012) — Tax Practitioners Board. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  33. Guide to valuing SMSF assets (QC 26343) — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.

Send an enquiry

Anything that helps: the date the value is needed for, the property type, any deadline from a court or an auditor.

We reply within [TBC: enquiry response time — ENQUIRY_RESPONSE_TIME]. Nothing is charged by sending this form.

Preview only. Your request is recorded locally; no email is sent.