Draft for review, not published

Appraisal vs valuation: what's the difference, and when does it matter?

Direct answer

A real estate agent's appraisal is an opinion of the price a property might sell for, usually free and given to win a listing. A valuation is a qualified valuer's signed, independent opinion of market value at a stated date, with the evidence set out. For SMSF accounts the ATO accepts appraisals that list comparable sales; for tax events and court, an independent valuation carries more weight.

This comparison is part of our guide to property valuation reports. The short version: an appraisal tells you what an agent thinks the property might sell for; a valuation tells you what a valuer, with nothing riding on the figure, thinks it is worth at a given date, and shows why.

The difference in one table

Agent appraisalValuation (inspected)
Who prepares itA licensed real estate agentA Certified Practising Valuer
What it givesA likely selling price, often to win a listingMarket value at a stated date
InspectionOftenBy the valuer who signs; required under API rules
IndependenceThe agent may hope to sell the propertyIndependence declared; fee not tied to the value
Evidence shownVaries; often a few recent salesSales evidence, method and a cross-check
Meets the ATO's report content listNoYes
Usual costUsually freeAbout $399 to $646 published (full inspection)
SMSF annual accountsAcceptable if it lists the comparable sales relied onYes
CGT events, court, most stamp dutyWeakYes

Sources: ATO market valuation guidance12; ATO SMSF guide3; API CGT guidance5; API Rule 11.26. Price range: providers’ own published entry prices, checked 17 November 2026.

What an appraisal is

An appraisal is a real estate agent’s opinion of the price a property might sell for. Agents base it on recent sales nearby and on what is listed for sale now. It is usually free, because for the agent it is often the first step in winning the listing.

An appraisal is not a valuation. It is not a valuer’s signed opinion of market value at a stated date, and the agent has an interest in the outcome if they hope to sell the property. None of that makes an appraisal useless. An experienced local agent often knows a market well, and an appraisal is a sensible starting point when you are deciding whether to sell.

What a valuation is

A valuation is a qualified valuer’s opinion of market value at a stated date. The ATO describes market value as “the estimated monetary worth of an asset on the open market at a particular time”, what a willing buyer and seller would agree at arm’s length.1

Three things set a valuation apart:

  • An inspection by the person who signs. Under the Australian Property Institute’s Rule 11.2, a valuation requires a physical inspection by the Primary Valuer.6
  • A report with set content. The ATO lists what a tax valuation should include: purpose, scope, the valuation date, the inspection date, the basis of value, method, a single value, the valuer’s qualifications and an independence declaration, among others.12
  • Independence. When you properly instruct a valuer, the ATO expects you to acknowledge the valuer’s independence and state that the fee does not depend on the outcome.1

What the ATO says about appraisals

The ATO treats appraisals differently depending on the purpose.

For SMSF annual accounts, an appraisal can be acceptable. The ATO’s SMSF guide says a valuation by a provider, “including online services or a real estate agent, are acceptable”. If it is the only evidence, it should list the comparable sales relied on, and “Generally, it is not sufficient for valuations to be based on only one item of evidence”.3 The ATO’s guidance for auditors says an appraisal without the sales relied on “would generally not on its own be sufficient”.4

For CGT and other tax events, it is weaker evidence. The ATO judges the process rather than the person: “the acceptability of a valuation usually depends on the valuation process undertaken rather than who conducted it”. But it also says “valuations undertaken by professional valuers are more credible than those provided by someone who isn’t a professional valuer”.12

The ATO has a penalty example on point. In it, a taxpayer relied on a $1.8 million appraisal from her husband’s agency in a related-party sale; the State Revenue Office’s value was $2.3 million. The ATO applied an intentional-disregard penalty.2

The Australian Property Institute’s view is blunter: agent appraisals will not meet the ATO’s expectation of independence.5

Stamp duty

Revenue offices decide what evidence of value they accept, and they differ.

  • Victoria: the State Revenue Office says agent appraisals are not formal valuations. It requires a valuer certified by the Australian Property Institute with experience valuing that type of property.8
  • Queensland: the public ruling for residential property accepts independent agents who give at least three comparable sales, as well as registered valuers.9
  • Other states and territories require a qualified valuer, or rely on the Valuer-General’s value. Western Australia, for example, prefers a licensed valuer’s inspected report, and South Australia’s guidance (a 2017 circular) sends evidence of value to the Valuer-General.1112

When an appraisal may be enough, and when it isn’t

An appraisal may be enough for:

  • deciding whether, and when, to sell
  • SMSF annual accounts, where it lists the comparable sales relied on and sits alongside at least one other item of evidence. Your auditor decides.3

An appraisal is usually not enough for:

  • CGT events: a sale, a gift, an inheritance, or the date you first rented out your home
  • related-party and family transfers, where market value replaces the price and the ATO’s penalty example applies
  • family law and court, where experts owe their duty to the court
  • stamp duty in most states
  • the 1 July 2027 CGT reset. The ATO has not yet said what kind of valuation it will accept; it promised guidance on 19 October 2026.7 The API recommends a comprehensive inspection report “for a value the tax system relies on”.5 A valuation is optional for the reset; the alternative is the apportionment formula. More in our 1 July 2027 CGT valuation guide.

For events other than the reset, see our capital gains tax valuation guide.

Cost

An agent’s appraisal is usually free. A valuation is not. Published prices for a full inspection of a standard home ranged from about $399 to $646 in November 2026 (providers’ own published entry prices, checked 17 November 2026; ranges, not quotes).

Our own prices, each one total including GST:

Report Price Label
Market value estimate $195 Not a valuation
Desktop valuation (CPV-signed, no inspection) $249 Signed by a CPV · indicative value under API rules. Not for CGT cost base or court
Inspected valuation $550 ($495 early bird) Valuation, signed by a CPV
Specialist valuation Quoted, from $650 Valuation, signed by a CPV

If you want a figure between a free appraisal and a full valuation, our Market value estimate is a model’s figure checked by staff; it is not a valuation. For a valuation, see the Inspected valuation. The full price picture is in our property valuation cost guide, and our prices are on the pricing page.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a real estate agent's appraisal for CGT?

The ATO doesn't ban it, but warns about using unqualified valuers, and one of its penalty examples involved a non-independent agent appraisal in a family sale. The API says agent appraisals won't meet the ATO's independence requirement. For SMSF accounts the ATO accepts agent appraisals that list comparable sales.

Is an agent appraisal or online report enough for an SMSF?

The ATO's SMSF guide says reports from valuation providers, "including online services or a real estate agent, are acceptable", but if that is the only evidence the report should list the comparable sales relied on, and one item of evidence is generally not enough. Auditors must see sufficient appropriate evidence of market value.

Can a real estate agent's appraisal be used for stamp duty?

Generally not in Victoria, where the SRO says agent appraisals are not formal valuations and requires an API-certified valuer. Queensland's ruling for residential property accepts independent agents who give at least three comparable sales, as well as registered valuers. Other states require a qualified valuer or accept the Valuer-General's value.

Two agents gave me very different figures. Which is right?

Possibly neither, exactly. Both are opinions of the price the property might sell for, not valuations, and agents can reasonably differ, particularly when each hopes to win the listing. Neither has to show its evidence. Where someone else will rely on the figure, a valuation sets out the comparable sales, the method and the date, so the reasoning can be checked.

Can I use the property manager's figure when I start renting my home?

The ATO says "You must get a market valuation of your home when you first start using it for rental", though a later valuation is acceptable if necessary. It judges a valuation by the process behind it rather than who did it, but says professional valuations are more credible. A property manager's figure is an opinion that rarely shows its evidence. Ask your registered tax agent what your situation needs.

Sources

  1. Market valuation of assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  2. Market valuation for tax purposes — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  3. Guide to valuing SMSF assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  4. Verifying the market value of fund assets — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  5. The CGT Changes and Property Valuations: What you need to know — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  6. Rules of Professional Conduct (effective 1 August 2025) — Australian Property Institute. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  7. CGT reform – guidance and market valuations — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  8. Valuation of land for duty purposes — State Revenue Office Victoria. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  9. Public Ruling DA505.1.2 — Queensland Revenue Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  10. Using your home for rental or business — Australian Taxation Office. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  11. Transfer duty assessment — WA Department of Treasury and Finance. Accessed 17/11/2026.
  12. Information Circular 102 — RevenueSA. Accessed 17/11/2026.

Send an enquiry

Anything that helps: the date the value is needed for, the property type, any deadline from a court or an auditor.

We reply within [TBC: enquiry response time — ENQUIRY_RESPONSE_TIME]. Nothing is charged by sending this form.

Preview only. Your request is recorded locally; no email is sent.